How to Create A Killer Short Story Unit for Your Middle Schoolers: Part 4 - EB Academics

Grab Your Free Writing Guide

Become an EB Insider Today

How to Create A Killer Short Story Unit for Your Middle Schoolers: Part 4

November 30, 2018 3 min read

How to Create A Killer Short Story Unit for Your Middle Schoolers: Part 4

November 30, 2018 3 min read

We’ve made it! We’re at the end of our 4-part series where we’re walking you through 4 easy steps to creating an awesome short story unit for your middle school students! If you missed the previous posts you can read them here: Part 1, Part 2, and Part 3

As mentioned in the previous three posts, when creating our short story units for middle school, we always aim to include four main elements:

  • A hook
  • A high-interest story (see our list of favorite story stories in this post)
  • Standards-aligned activities
  • An assessment
Our final post to creating an awesome short story unit is all about …

We always like to give our middle schoolers various ways to demonstrate their knowledge and grasp of the content and objectives for our units. Short story units are no exception.

Instead of just giving students a standard “assessment,” we like to give them THREE.

Now, we know this sounds like a lot, but hear us out.

You will always have students who struggle with test taking. You will also always have students who are incredibly creative. And then you will have those students who love to write, but can’t draw to save their life (that’s me!).

So why wouldn’t we want to provide each type of learner with a different way to show what they have learned? Which is precisely why we provide students with three summative assessments at the end of any unit.

Those three assessments are:

1. Your Basic Test
Yep! You read that right. We do give students one of those “basic tests,” and we actually think they’re quite important. But they’re not the end all be all. On a test, you’ll find reading comprehension questions, short answer analytical questions, matching characters to quotes, true or false, etc.

2. A Project-Based Assessment
We always find it important to give students who are more project-based learners a way to express what they’ve learned. Which is why we this resource this Project Bingo Board (which also allows for excellent differentiation).

Just check out some of the incredible work our students have produced in the past!

Easily create a short story unit for your middle school english classroom
Easily create a short story unit for your middle school english classroom

3. An In-Class Essay.
Always the final formative assessment, the in-class essay in a staple in our curriculum. Because we follow the framework we have developed over the years (which we call Evidence-Based Writing, and you can read more about here), we want to be continuously assessing our students on their ability to write a Response to Literature.

Which is precisely why they write an in-class essay at least 7 times a year.

The in-class essay prompt that we provide students will always be focused on them analyzing the text, forming a claim, citing evidence, and forming justification. Hitting those standards, right? But also preparing them for much more in life than just writing an essay. Forming claims and providing evidence to support those claims is an incredible skill for so many areas in life!

Want to provide differentiation for this type of an assessment? You can use this same Response to Literature graphic organizer that we developed and have fine tuned over the years.
Would you like to use the short story unit we do? You can grab it here.
Do you have another idea for creating a short story unit? Please let us know in the comments below or by sending us an email.
Your ELA Friends,
Save this post for later! 
Easily create a short story unit for your middle school english classroom

All posts


  • […] Ready to dive into Part 4 for how to create an awesome short story unit. You can do so here.  […]

  • Leave a Reply

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.



    Hi there! We're two middle school ELA teachers with a mission to share ideas, tips, and tricks for effectively teaching reading and writing in the secondary classroom. We're so happy you stopped by!

    Caitlin + Jessica

    Your 15 Free Resources Are Waiting!

    Immediately receive access to our
    Free Resource Library

    We promise we won't spam you.

    Let’s Connect

    Popular Posts

    Our Latest Posts



    • This honestly might be my favorite tip I’ve EVER come across on IG. EVER!!! 🤗🤗🤗 It’s from my friend Melissa @readingandwritinghaven ⁣
It’s meant to ensure you’re not teaching writing genres in isolation. KEY 👌🏼 ⁣
Here’s how it works:⁣
- Take a topic and put it in the middle⁣
- Brainstorm possible titles or questions related to that topic that could be addressed in different genres ⁣
- Give students choice and have them pick 1-2 genres to write ⁣
Honestly. Brilliant. ⁣
Thanks @readingandwritinghaven !! And if you aren’t a fan of Melissa yet, you definitely should be 😘♥️
    • It’s about this time of year that I always seem to think about quitting. Every year. Without fail. ⁣
And I think it’s because it’s the hardest part. ⁣
Just like how at the gym you think there’s no way in HECK you can do that last push-up or that last squat. ⁣
May is that last lunge. ⁣
But I remind myself every time, that I’ve left teaching twice only to be MISERABLE. ⁣
The grass almost always looks greener. But it’s not always greener. ⁣
Just take care of yourself, let things go, give every piece of effort, and then enjoy your summer knowing you reached deep within yourself to make it there. ⁣
And make it there happily, filled with contentment. ⁣
Happy Friday in May, friends. Love you guys 😘 📸 @carlacoulson
    • Tell me what you’re teaching right now 👇🏼 Seriously! Let’s get a catalogue of awesome content, so we can all learn from each other!⁣
I’m currently teaching a fan favorite “The Cask of Amontillado” - the irony, the foreshadowing, the evil soul of Montressor ... it is SO GOOD. ⁣
Anyhow, we’re still trucking along to the end! Keeping it interesting and engaging with great lit!⁣
Love you guys 😘 Keep up the good work!
    • When is your bedtime? Because please tell me I’m not the only one 🙋🏼‍♀️🤷🏼‍♀️ (I might even change that to 8:30 at this point 😆).⁣
Happy Monday, friends 💕 ⁣
Let’s kick this week off with a bang! I’ve got an awesome podcast episode coming out tomorrow with my friend, Holly @researchandplay and next week’s episode is going to be *JUST* what you need to hear this time of year. ⁣
Love you guys! 😘
    • My Mom’s best advice ...?⁣
Life is short. Drink the Chardonnay. Eat the carbs. Travel the world 😂😘 (Which is precisely what we’re doing in this pic from our last trip to Italy together) ♥️ Gotta love her. ⁣⁣⁣⁣
Happy Mother’s Day! I am a proud momma to my little William and two furry boys, Charlie and Huckleberry 👶🏼🐕🐕 and just want to celebrate all the women in our lives - whether you are a mom, hoping to become a mom, or don’t have the desire to be a mom. ⁣
Women are amazing!⁣
What’s your mom’s best advice?
    • Double tap if this students’ response was on point and made you laugh 😂😆 Honestly this is one of my favorite IG posts I’ve ever seen! Thanks @helloteacherlady for spreading the laughs 🤗

    Follow @ebacademics